Enter the River Study Guide
Session 8: Wrestling with privileges
- Handout for Session 8: Race as science
- Handout for Session 8: Dates
- Video.
View the video Free Indeed and discuss questions
in the accompanying study guide. Free Indeed explores the realities of
White privilege among young adults wanting to do a service project in a Black
community.
- Discussion monitor.
If you are doing this study in an all-White
congregation, you may want to consider inviting a person of color to monitor
this discussion. Don't invite a person of color in to fill this role unless
you are clear why you are doing so. Given that privileges of any kind are
difficult to identify by those who receive them, having someone present who is
aware of the idea of White privilege and can provide additional feedback can
sharpen the process of identification.
The process can be somewhat uncomfortable for those who are not used to
such accountability, but it can also result in new, deeper growth for the
group. Introduce the listener(s) and be sure to set aside adequate time at the
end of the class for them to share feedback. This idea may be used in this
session or other sessions.
- Privilege identification.
Read privileges collected and put on
news sheets. Identify different privilege areas. Examples: assumptions of
trustworthiness; ability to fit in; access to information, job networks, family
resources; control of time; setting norms and standards of behavior, dress,
etc.
- Responding to privileges.
Pick one privilege and plan how to
respond to situation either through brainstorming or role play. For example,
someone is invited to be part of a board that has no people of color on it.
The person responds by saying, "It's not my turn."
- Chapter 7 discussion questions:
- The author states "my Whiteness is probably the foremost determiner
of success or failure in the life ahead of me" (103). Ask class members to
physically position themselves on a continuum with one side of the room
representing complete agreement and the other side complete disagreement. Ask
for representative comments about why people have positioned themselves where
they have.
- In a very brief section (105-107), Whiteness and race are described
as myths. Re-read this section carefully. What beliefs have you been taught
about the "races"? What physical or mental attributes have been assigned to
which groups? Does this section suggest those characteristics have any
"scientific basis"? Did those who have come to be called White lose anything
in the process? For a fuller discussion of race see the accompanying handout,
"Race as science."
- Do those of us who are White have to know about White privileges for
them to be given to us? Do we have to be aware of them for the privilege to
come our way? Dale Taylor, a Mennonite Central Committee Canada executive,
observes that White folks don't have to see the privilege because it is behind
us holding us up. How can we encourage each other to be more honest about the
privileges we receive? How can we learn the skills to identify them around
us?
- At this point, over half-way through the study, how are you feeling?
Do you identify any of the emotions outlined in this chapter (112-113)? Strong
emotions are to be expected in a discussion of an issue that gets so directly
to core understanding of identity. Take time to share those emotions, explore
their source, recognize that a similar cycle to that of grieving may also be in
place.
- Homework assignment:
Read Chapter 8: How Can We Celebrate Our Cultures.
Bring in one item from your culture that causes you to celebrate.
|