Enter the River Study Guide
Session 8: Wrestling with privileges
Handout for Session 8: Race as science
"If the holocaust comes and a small tribe deep in the New Guinea
forests
are the only survivors, almost all of the genetic variation now expressed among
the innumerable groups of four billion people will be preserved."
Linda R. Maxson and Charles H. Daugherty
Racial indicators
Anders Retzius invented the cephalic index, which differentiated
people
with round heads (those with high ratios of skull width to length) from those
with long heads (those with low ratios of skull width to length). Long-headed
(dolichocephalic) populations were interpreted to be more advanced than
round-headed people (brachycephalic).
Paul Broca (round headed himself) used quantitative methods of determining
races according to phrenological (the study of skulls for the purpose of
determining personality traits and talents of individuals and entire ethnic
populations) assumptions. Invented instruments used by craniometrists in the
science of anthropometry (the science of measuring bodies).
Race in North America: Origin and Evolution of a Worldview. Audrey
Smedley. San Francisco: Westview Press, 1993.
Other possible means of dividing the human family (taxonomy)
include:
sickle-cell gene providing more resistance to malaria; enzyme lactase making it
possible to digest the milk sugar lactose; body shape giving ability to inhibit
or encourage heat loss; sex appeal determinants such as size of breasts and
buttocks, among of body hair, nipple color; fingerprints (arches, loops, and
whorls) which provide no survival or sexual function at all.
"Race Without Color," Jared Diamond. Discover, November
1994.
"Color pigment is to be found in the dermis, and is a substance
called
melanin. Melanin is usually black, although some granules of it are as light
as bright yellow. The color of the skin is determined not by the color of the
pigment so much as by the quantity of it - the same coloring matter, in
different amounts, colors the skin of all the races. The same pigments also
color the eye and the hair."
"In a study of Swedish army recruits of forty years ago, . . . five 'Nordic
traits' were taken, and it was discovered that less than ten percent of the
recruits had all the traits. . . .Similar studies were made in Switzerland.
Six percent of the Swiss were 'pure' Alpine racial types. No more than six
percent fitted the stereotype . . . ."
Paul Bohannan, Social Anthropology
"Dividing people by the amount of melanin in their skin and then
asserting
that this correlates with intelligence or behavior patterns make no more sense
than suggesting that intelligence correlates with one's blood type - which
certainly constitutes a more fundamental physical difference. As Erika Vora
notes, 'About 95% of DNA molecules are identical for all human beings. The
remaining 5% are responsible for all the differences in appearance . . . . The
differences that do exist between [races] are few and for the most part
superficial.'"
Donald S. Will, Teaching Peace Through Debunking Race
Session 8: Wrestling with privileges
|