Bound by hospitality
March 12, 2013
Editor’s note: This article first appeared in the online edition of PBS’s Religion and Ethics Newsweekly , March 8, 2013.
AMMAN, Jordan – They keep coming. On an average night more than 2,100 Syrians cross the border into Jordan, seeking refuge from the violence and instability in their own country.
It’s the new normal, the head of a large humanitarian aid organization working in the Za’atari Refugee Camp told me recently. “We’ve come to expect several thousand refugees each night.”
March 15 marks the second anniversary of the Syrian revolution.
According to the United Nations, in those two short years, more than 70,000 Syrians have been killed and over 3 million have been uprooted from their homes. Some 2.3 million Syrians are internally displaced and another 1.0 million are refugees in Jordan, Lebanon, Turkey, Iraq and Egypt.
According to the Jordanian government, more than 400,000 Syrians now live in Jordan – a country of only 6.5 million people with a long history of welcoming refugees.
Because of the harsh desert climate, the Bedouin offered a minimum of three days of hospitality to anyone who passed by their tents.
“The house is always opened to guests,” says Dr. Kamal Abu Jaber, the former foreign minister of Jordan and son of a Jordanian Bedouin father and Palestinian mother. “Once you eat bread and salt together you are bound together as family.”
To call a Jordanian “generous” is the highest compliment, he reflects.
Well over half the population of Jordan is made up of newcomers who have arrived during the past 60 years. Jordan has opened its arms to 2.7 million Palestinians (the original refugees from 1948 and 1967 wars, and their descendants); half a million Iraqis; thousands of Somalis, Sudanese and Libyans; and now to more than 400,000 Syrians.
“It’s a miracle that this poor country can do this,” ponders Abu Jaber.
Za’atari Refugee Camp
In early March, I visited the sprawling Za’atari Refugee Camp only six miles from the Syrian border and just outside the northern Jordanian city of Mafraq.
All new Syrian arrivals in Jordan are brought first to Za’atari. Those few who are fortunate enough to find a Jordanian citizen to sponsor them are free to leave the camp, which is surrounded by a high fence and guarded by Jordanian security. Others must stay in the camp.
The camp is now home to as many as 140,000 Syrians. No one seems to know the exact number. The situation is fluid and volatile by anyone’s definition. There are frequent protests and riots.
According to aid workers, many of the refugees come from middle-class households and are quick to express frustration about the camp’s limited services and fragile infrastructure. In spite of heroic efforts, U.N. and aid agencies are simply not able to keep pace with the thousands who arrive daily.
Za’atari is in the middle of a high-altitude desert that is cold and wet in the winter and stiflingly hot with sand storms in the summer. Newcomers live in tents. Eventually families are transferred to small one-room “caravans.”
The main street of the camp is packed with pedestrians and lined with vendors selling fruits, vegetables, household supplies and even washing machines.
Eighty-eight-year-old Um Omar (names changed for security reasons) welcomed us in her 10-foot by 15-foot caravan with no furnishings except mats on the floor. She served us tea, with heaping plates of bananas and oranges.
She came to Za'atari from Dara’a five months ago, along with two grown sons, who carried her across the border, and a gaggle of grandchildren.
Dara’a is where Syria’s revolution began in March 2011, when several young boys were arrested for painting graffiti about Syria’s President Assad.
Her grandchildren do not go to school because it is too far away from their caravan. Indeed, the camp is so massive that many residents no longer live within easy walking distance of schools, medical facilities or other services.
Her son Omar fears that the Syrian regime might fire scud missiles at Za’atari because it is so close to the border.
Contrary to popular images, the vast majority of Syrians in Jordan do not live in refugee camps. Most arrived before Za’atari was opened in late July 2012.
These “urban refugees” live with Jordanian families or rent small rooms or apartments in cities like Amman, Irbid, Mafraq and Zarqa. Sometimes three or four families live in an apartment with only three or four rooms.
More than 75 percent of the Syrian refugees in Jordan are women and children. Many arrive traumatized by the violence they have witnessed in Syria.
In addition to feelings of isolation and trauma, refugees express fears about meeting their current needs and uncertainty about the future.
Some 316,000 Syrians have registered or are in the process of registering with the Office of the U.N. High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR), qualifying them to receive rent assistance, medical care, access to Jordanian public schools and other humanitarian aid.
But as many as 100,000 Syrians have chosen not to register – some out of fear that there will be reprisals from the Syrian government.
The U.N. and aid agencies estimate that it will cost $1.0 billion to cover the costs of Syrian refugees in the region just for the six months from January to June 2013.
Mennonite Central Committee (MCC) – an international humanitarian agency of Anabaptist churches – partners with local agencies in Jordan to distribute shipments of MCC relief kits, school kits and blankets; dispense infant milk powder, diapers, and children’s shoes purchased in local markets; and provide non-formal education and psycho-social support to the refugees.
MCC has partnered with Caritas Jordan since 2005, supporting an innovative HIV and AIDS awareness project, a revolving loan fund for low-income Jordanian students and distribution of school kits and milk powder to vulnerable families.
With tensions increasing between Jordanian host communities and an increasingly diverse and vulnerable group of Syrian refugees, Caritas has added a peacebuilding component to its services – training teams of Syrian refugees and Jordanians to work together to provide an effective response to the crisis.
Another key role for MCC is to share stories of the refugees and the need in the United States and Canada. Many refugees are eager to share, but do not wish to have their pictures taken or to give their full names, fearing that the Syrian regime will retaliate against them.
Still working with refugees
Caritas Jordan was established in 1967 to respond to the refugee and humanitarian crisis caused by the Six-Day War in neighboring Palestine and Israel.
Some 45 years later, Caritas is still working with refugees.
Caritas is guided by the vision of affirming the dignity of every human, with a special concern for the poor. Caritas offers services to Christians and Muslims.
“We look at the refugees’ needs and try to answer it,” says Wael Sulieman, executive director.
Caritas Jordan works closely with local churches, often using parish facilities as distribution centers.
The organization has registered more than 75,000 Syrian refugees at its centers in Amman, Husson, Irbid, Madaba, Mafraq, Ramtha, Salt and Zarqa, doing family needs assessments before distributing humanitarian assistance and providing medical and educational resources.
Caritas tries to avoid duplicating services provided by the UNHCR.
“Our work with the vulnerable Jordanian families has never stopped,” says Sulieman. “Nonetheless Caritas gives a helping hand to any refugee community who needs help, beginning with Palestinians in the 1960s, Iraqis in the 1990s and now with Syrians.”
The burdens of hospitality
Hospitality has its costs.
Whether or not they work for humanitarian organizations, “Jordanians are heavily involved in serving and hosting the Syrians,” says Wafa Goussous, director of the Orthodox Initiative for the Churches in the Middle East. “With the heavy load that Jordan is taking, part of the load is definitely carried by its citizens.”
The influx of refugees is straining Jordan’s budget and infrastructure and, in some cases, increasing social tensions between the refugees and Jordanian host communities.
Some Jordanians have begun to complain about rising food and housing costs which they believe are linked to yet another wave of refugees.
Jordan’s Economic and Social Council recently reported that the economic cost of hosting the refugees for the past 18 months exceeded $833 million, representing about 3 percent of Jordan’s gross domestic product.
More than 29,000 Syrian children are enrolled in Jordanian public schools at a cost of $19.8 million. Still, some Syrians report being turned away from public schools due to overcrowding. And according to MCC partner Jesuit Refugee Services (JRS), many Syrian families cannot afford to send their children to public school kindergarten, for which the fees have not been waived.
But many refugees don’t simply want hand outs. When one JRS staff member recently encouraged a Syrian woman to register with UNHCR so that she would qualify for a range of benefits, she responded, “I don’t want 50 Jordanian Dinars (about $70 USD) from UNHCR. I want to work!”
The need for employment has strained the Jordanian economy as well. So far 38,000 jobs have been offered to Syrians, contributing to growing unemployment rates in Jordan.
Some wealthier Syrians are moving their businesses to Jordan, creating stiff competition for Jordanian companies.
“Syrians are managing to cut production costs by operating from apartments, hiring refugees and avoiding taxation,” garment factory owner Ebrahim Hadad recently told The Media Line. “Syrians are welcomed; this country is comprised of refugees,” Hadad continued. “However, they are hurting our businesses. I am unable to compete with them.”
But many refugees with fewer resources report that they are often exploited by Jordanian employers and made to work long hours at low wages because they do not have work permits.
Some married Syrian women work at low-wage farms. Syrian male heads of household in Amman are reported to work in low-wage jobs as bakers, construction workers and security guards.
According to Caritas Jordan, Syrian youth are often spotted as street peddlers, beggars and market helpers, instead of attending school or summer camps.
Balancing the needs of Jordanians and refugees is critical. In order to reduce tensions between refugees and the resource-stretched host communities, the Jordanian government now requires 30 percent of international humanitarian aid to be made available for vulnerable Jordanian families.
And hospitality is not without risks.
Jordan has long had a reputation as one of the most stable countries in the Middle East. But some analysts say ferment is growing. They fear that the new influx of Syrian refugees might push Jordan’s tottering social stability over the edge.
Others fear that groups like al-Qaeda will infiltrate the refugees and attack targets in Jordan. There are also reports of skirmishes on the Syrian-Jordanian border, as Jordanian forces help refugees enter the country and the Syrian regime responds.
Still, Jordan continues to follow an open-door policy and provides healthcare and access to public education for Syrians who register with UNHCR.
Some Syrians express optimism that they will be able to return home soon. Others believe it will take many years – just as has been the case with Palestinians and Iraqis still living in Jordan.
“They all wish the fighting in Syria will end tomorrow,” says George Akil, a program manager for Caritas Jordan. “They are all eager to go back to their homes once the fighting ends.”
While some Jordanian officials hint that they may eventually close the border, Dr. Abu Jaber, who now heads the Royal Institute for Interfaith Studies, disagrees.
“There is no way by our tradition, our culture or our religion that we can close the door,” he said. “How can you close the door when women and children are suffering and without food?”
But with thousands of Syrians continuing to arrive every night, and with UNHCR estimating that 660,000 Syrians will be in Jordan by the end of 2013, it will take another miracle for this small country to absorb them all.
Mennonite Central Committee: Relief, development and peace in the name of Christ